Hierarchical Authority of Indonesia’s Professional Disciplinary Board in Medical Malpractice: Ambiguity, Evidence, and Constitutional Legitimacy
Abstract
Medical malpractice lies at the intersection of healthcare and criminal law. In Indonesia, Law Number 17 of 2023 on Health introduced the Professional Disciplinary Board (Majelis Disiplin Profesi/MDP), replacing the MKDKI and granting it expanded authority, including recommending criminal investigations. Article 308(1) requires a prior MDP recommendation before prosecution, positioning the MDP as a procedural gatekeeper while creating ambiguity over whether its examination is mandatory or discretionary.This study analyzes the hierarchical authority of the MDP in managing medical malpractice cases, focusing on the evidentiary challenges in proving criminal elements and their implications for criminal law reform. Using a normative juridical approach combining statutory, conceptual, and case analyses, the study finds that Article 308(1) creates a de jure mandatory MDP review requirement that operates as de facto discretionary, producing fundamental legal uncertainty, cases bypassing the MDP suffer from procedural invalidity concerns, evidentiary quality deficiencies due to loss of specialized technical review, and inconsistent judicial outcomes across different court levels, and the MDP's constitutional legitimacy as a pre-judicial gatekeeper is questionable due to insufficient procedural safeguards (14-working-day timeframe), unclear separation of powers between administrative and judicial functions, and violation of the lex certa (legal certainty) principle essential to criminal law
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Alfina, Sita Tahta, and Arie Mangesti Yovita. “Peran Majelis Disiplin Profesi Dalam Penyelesaian Sengketa Medis Ditinjau Dari Undang-Undang Nomor 17 Tahun 2023 Tentang Kesehatan.” Quantum Juris: Jurnal Hukum Modern 7, no. 1 (January 1, 2025). https://journalversa.com/s/index.php/jhm/article/view/801.
Amiati, Mia, Hamzah Halim, and Jady Zaidi Hassim. “Navigating Ambiguity: Critiques of Indonesia’s Health Law and Its Impact on Legal Redress for Medical Malpractice Victims.” Hasanuddin Law Review 10, no. 1 (June 8, 2024): 94. doi:10.20956/halrev.v10i1.5346.
Anjum, Rani Lill, and Elena Rocca. “When a Cause Cannot Be Found.” In Rethinking Causality, Complexity and Evidence for the Unique Patient, 55–74. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2020. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-41239-5_4.
Ardi, Muhammad Khalif, F X Hastowo Broto Laksito, and Andriamalala Laurent. “Role and Position of Indonesian Medical Disciplinary Honour Council: Fair Medical Dispute Resolution.” Journal of Law, Environmental and Justice 1, no. 3 (2023): 185–201. doi:10.62264/jlej.v1i3.15.
Bal, Sonny B. “An Introduction to Medical Malpractice in the United States.” Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research 467, no. 2 (February 2009): 339–47. doi:10.1007/s11999-008-0636-2.
Brazier, Margaret, Emma Cave, and Rob Heywood. “The Criminal Process and and Medical Malpractice.” In Medicine, Patients and the Law, 273–86. Manchester University Press, 2023. doi:10.7765/9781526157188.00020.
Christiani, Theresia Anita. “Normative and Empirical Research Methods: Their Usefulness and Relevance in the Study of Law as an Object.” Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 219 (May 2016): 201–7. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2016.05.006.
DA, Ady Thea. “Menkes Budi: Malpraktik Tak Bisa Langsung Diproses Pidana,” July 2, 2025. https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/a/menkes-budi--malpraktik-tak-bisa-langsung-diproses-pidana-lt6864c872b22cc/?utm_source=chatgpt.com.
Dinarjati Eka Puspitasari. “Aspek Hukum Penanganan Tindakan Malpraktek Medik Di Indonesia.” Lambung Mangkurat Law Journal 3, no. 2 (September 30, 2018): 242–61. doi:10.32801/abc.v3i2.64.
Fekry, Moussa Ahmed, Ibrahim Suleiman Al Qatawneh, Ramzi Madi, Moustafa Elmetwaly Kandeel, and Maher Haswa. “Penal Liability Arising from Medical Malpractice: A Comparative Study of Egypt and France.” Pakistan Journal of Life and Social Sciences 21, no. 2 (2023): 793–806. doi:10.57239/PJLSS-2023-21.2.0019.
Ghozali, Muhammad, Cut Afra, Deddi Agusriadi, and Sudirman Suti. “Legal Consequences of Medical Accidents and Medical Malpractice in Indonesia.” International Journal of Law, Social Science, and Humanities 1, no. 2 (November 25, 2024): 76–82. doi:10.70193/ijlsh.v1i2.159.
Herningtyas, Tuti, Endah Labati, and Anna Veronica Pont. “Legal Aspects of Medical Malpractice: Patient Protection and Physician Liability.” International Journal of Health, Economics, and Social Sciences (IJHESS) 7, no. 2 (April 30, 2025): 860~865-860~865. doi:10.56338/IJHESS.V7I2.7360.
Honig, Richard. Kausalitaet Und Objektive Zurechnung, 1930. https://books.google.co.id/books/about/Kausalitaet_und_objektive_Zurechnung.html?id=CqBLvwEACAAJ&redir_esc=y.
Indrawan, Khadafi, M. Fakih, and Budiyono Budiyono. “Peran Majelis Kehormatan Disiplin Kedokteran Indonesia Dalam Kasus Pelanggaran Standar Profesional Dokter.” Justicia Sains: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum 9, no. 2 (November 30, 2024): 455–69. doi:10.24967/jcs.v9i2.3288.
Irawati, Sri Ayu. “Perbedaan Sengaja Dan Tidak Sengaja Dalam Hukum Pidana.” Ideas: Jurnal Pendidikan, Sosial, Dan Budaya 10, no. 4 (November 28, 2024): 1137. doi:10.32884/ideas.v10i4.1973.
Koterov, A. N. “Causal Criteria in Medical and Biological Disciplines: History, Essence, and Radiation Aspect. Report 1. Problem Statement, Conception of Causes and Causation, False Associations.” Biology Bulletin 46, no. 11 (December 19, 2019): 1458–88. doi:10.1134/S1062359019110165.
Landro, Andrea R Di. “Criminal Law as a Response to Medical Malpractice: Pluses and Minuses-Comparing Italian and US Experiences.” Med. & L. 31 (2012): 221.
Lazuardi, Irwan, and Siti Marwiyah. “Analysis of Informed Consent as the Legal Protection of Physician Relationships and Patients in Malpractice Case.” Policy Law Notary Regul 2, no. 4 (2023): 327–338. doi:10.55047/polri.v2i4.774.
Marzuki, Mahmud. Penelitian Hukum. Kencana, 2017. https://books.google.co.id/books?id=CKZADwAAQBAJ&printsec=copyright#v=onepage&q&f=false.
Mustafa, Ghulam, and Ede Surya Darmawan. “Strengthening Legal Frameworks and Patient Safety: A Narrative Review of Medical and Dental Malpractice in Indonesia.” Jurnal ARSI : Administrasi Rumah Sakit Indonesia 11, no. 1 (February 16, 2025): 2. doi:10.7454/arsi.v11i1.1185.
Nadeak, Jasmen Ojak Haholongan. “Penerapan Disiplin Profesi Sebagai Instrumen Penegakan Hukum Pidana Kesehatan Berbasis Keadilan Prosedural.” Proceeding Masyarakat Hukum Kesehatan Indonesia 1, no. 01 (December 30, 2024): 184–95. https://rumah-jurnal.com/index.php/pmhki/article/view/205.
Negara, Tunggul Ansari Setia. “Normative Legal Research in Indonesia: Its Originis and Approaches.” Audito Comparative Law Journal (ACLJ) 4, no. 1 (February 2, 2023): 1–9. doi:10.22219/aclj.v4i1.24855.
Olarte Parra, Camila, Lorenzo Bertizzolo, Sara Schroter, Agnès Dechartres, and Els Goetghebeur. “Consistency of Causal Claims in Observational Studies: A Review of Papers Published in a General Medical Journal.” BMJ Open 11, no. 5 (May 2021): e043339. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2020-043339.
Pantow, Jefta Calvin, Roy Ronny Lembong, and Harly Stanly Muaja. “Analisis Yuridis Terhadap Pelanggaran Pada Penanganan Profesi Medis Dan Kesehatan Dalam Undang-Undang Nomor 17 Tahun 2023 Tentang Kesehatan.” LEX ADMINISTRATUM 13, no. 3 (July 22, 2025). https://ejournal.unsrat.ac.id/v3/index.php/administratum/article/view/63025.
Radanović, Nina Mišić, and Ivan Vukušić. “Causation in Medical Malpractice.” EU and Comparative Law Issues and Challenges Series (ECLIC) 4 (2020): 771–97. doi:10.25234/eclic/11927.
Republik Indonesia. Law No. 1 of 2023 (2003). https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Search?keywords=UUD+NO+1+Tahun+2003&p=2.
———. “UU No. 17 Tahun 2023.” Accessed October 30, 2025. https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/details/258028/uu-no-17-tahun-2023.
———. “UU No. 29 Tahun 2004 Tentang Praktik Kedokteran.” Aturan Praktik Kedokteran, 2004, 157–80.
Rokan, Mustika Putra. “Royalty Management Arrangements for Song and/or Music Copyright: The Needs of Indonesian Musicians.” Locus: Jurnal Konsep Ilmu Hukum 1, no. 1 (December 31, 2021): 30–37. doi:10.56128/JKIH.V1I1.15.
Soekanto, Soerjono, and Sri Mamudji. Penelitian Hukum Normatif: Suatu Tinjauan Singkat, 1986. https://books.google.co.id/books/about/Penelitian_hukum_normatif.html?hl=id&id=_Y1GPAAACAAJ&redir_esc=y.
Sudarmanto, Alif Muhammad, Rospita Adelina Siregar, Eko Nurmardiansyah, and Hari Pudjo Nugroho. “Majelis Disiplin Profesi Sebagai Primum Remedium Berdasarkan Undang-Undang Nomor 17 Tahun 2023 Tentang Kesehatan.” Jurnal Hukum To-Ra : Hukum Untuk Mengatur Dan Melindungi Masyarakat 10, no. 3 (2024): 491–505. doi:10.55809/tora.v10i3.384.
Taylor, G. “Concepts of Intention in German Criminal Law.” Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 24, no. 1 (March 1, 2004): 99–127. doi:10.1093/ojls/24.1.99.
Tegnan, Hilaire. “Law and Medical Disciplinary Sanctions: Enhancing Medical Practice and Health Quality in Indonesia.” J. Legal Ethical & Regul. Isses 21 (2018): 1.
Thielscher, Michael. “Causality and the Qualification Problem.” Accessed October 30, 2025. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/2852121_Causality_and_the_Qualification_Problem.
Vuletić, Igor. “Medical Malpractice as a Separate Criminal Offense: A Higher Degree of Patient Protection or Merely a Sword above the Doctors’ Heads? The Example of the Croatian Legislative Model and the Experiences of Its Implementation.” Medicine, Law & Society 12, no. 2 (2019): 39–60. doi:10.18690/10.18690/mls.12.2.39-60.2019.
Wangga, Maria Silvya E. “Implementation of Restorative Justice in Criminal Cases in Indonesia,” August 30, 2022. https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=4204101.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.26532/jph.v12i3.49061
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
License URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
Jurnal Pembaharuan Hukum Indexed by :
 | Jurnal Pembaharuan Hukum | |
| Faculty of Law, Unissula | Copyright of Jurnal Pembaharuan Hukum | |
| Jalan Kaligawe Raya KM.4, Terboyo Kulon, Genuk, | ISSN 2580-3085 (Online) ISSN 2355-0481 (Print) | |
| Semarang, Central Java, Indonesia, 50112 | JPH is licensed under a |