Restoring Victims of Wrongful Arrest: Automatic Compensation through a Parallel Justice Approach

Erwin Susilo, Dharma Setiawan Negara, Lufsiana Lufsiana

Abstract


This study aims to analyze the weaknesses of the existing compensation mechanism for victims of wrongful arrest in the criminal justice system and to propose a reform model based on the principle of Parallel Justice (PJ). Although Indonesian law, particularly the Criminal Procedure Code and Government Regulation No. 92/2015, already provides a legal basis for compensation, the mechanism remains petition-based and dependent on victims’ initiative through pre-trial proceedings. Such a passive system creates structural injustice and fails to guarantee effective recovery for victims of state error. The research method used in this study is normative legal research, employing statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches. The statutory approach is applied to examine the positive law in Indonesia regarding compensation. The conceptual approach is used to analyze and reformulate the theory of compensation by incorporating the PJ framework developed by Susan Herman, which emphasizes proactive victim restoration. The comparative approach reviews practices in other jurisdictions such as Germany, the Netherlands, Italy, and the United States to identify models of automatic compensation that can be adapted into the Indonesian context. The novelty in this research is the application of the Parallel Justice concept—originally designed for crime victims in general—to the context of wrongful arrest caused by state authorities. This adaptation provides a new paradigm in Indonesian criminal procedure by positioning victims of wrongful arrest not merely as claimants but as individuals entitled to automatic state responsibility. Based on the research, it is concluded that adopting the PJ approach can create a more responsive, victim-oriented, and automatic compensation system. Such reform would strengthen the protection of human rights, enhance public trust in the legal system, and ensure that victims of wrongful arrest are restored fairly, quickly, and comprehensively.

Keywords


Compensation; Criminal; Justice; Procedure.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Journals:

Betts, Samuel Ulric. (2023) 'The Right to Freedom from Arbitrary Arrest and Detention: Article 9 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR)'. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4574802.

Budiman, Maman. (2020) 'THE APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 5 PARAGRAPH (1) LETTER B OF THE CORRUPTION ERADICATION LAW'. Judicial Journal 13, no. 1. https://doi.org/10.29123/jy.v13i1.391.

Bunch, Charlotte. (1990) 'Women's Rights as Human Rights: Toward a Re-Vision of Human Rights'. Human Rights Quarterly 12, no. 4. https://doi.org/10.2307/762496.

Cassell, Paul G. (2023) 'On the Importance of Listening to Crime Victims . . . Merciful and Otherwise'. Tex. L. Rev. 102, no. 7: 1381-1408. https://heinonline.org/hol-cgi-bin/get_pdf.cgi?handle=hein.journals/tlr102§ion=47.

Deset, Miloš, and Eva Szabová. (2020) 'The Victims and the Sufficiency of Their Rights in the Criminal Justice System'. Teka Komisji Prawniczej PAN Oddział w Lublinie 13, no. 2. https://doi.org/10.32084/tekapr.2020.13.2-11.

Green, Simon. (2013) '"The Victims" Movement and Restorative Justice'. In Handbook of Restorative Justice. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781843926191-18.

Hartono, M Rudi, and Ryan Aditama. (2022) 'A STUDY OF THE LEGAL PROTECTION OF A WRONGLY ARRESTED SUSPECT IN THE PERSPECTIVE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE LAW'. Legality: Journal of Law 14, no. 1. https://doi.org/10.33087/legalitas.v14i1.316.

Kusuma, I Made Wisnu Wijaya, I Made Sepud, and Ni Made Sukaryati Karma. (2020, September 26) 'Pretrial Legal Efforts in the Indonesian Criminal Justice System'. Journal of Legal Interpretation 1, no. 2: 73–77. https://doi.org/10.22225/juinhum.1.2.2438.73-77.

Liu, Jianhong. (2024) 'The Relationism Theory of Criminal Justice-A Paradigm Shift'. Asian Journal of Criminology 19, no. 1. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11417-024-09419-z.

Liu, Joseph Tzu Shuo. (2021) 'Preventive Detention of Dangerous Inmates: A Dialogue between Human Rights and Penal Regimes'. International Journal of Human Rights 25, no. 4. https://doi.org/10.1080/13642987.2020.1725486.

Maliha, George, Sara Gerke, I. Glenn Cohen, and Ravi B. Parikh. (2021) 'Artificial Intelligence and Liability in Medicine: Balancing Safety and Innovation'. Milbank Quarterly 99, no. 3. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0009.12504.

Marbun, Rocky. (2021) 'Trichotomy of Relationships in Suspect Designation: Examining the Phrase "Examination of Prospective Suspects" Through Pretrial'. Undang: Law Journal 4, no. 1. https://doi.org/10.22437/ujh.4.1.159-190.

Naughton, Michael. 'Theorising Miscarriages of Justice'. Islamic Perspective 28 (2022): 93-118. https://dustinjbyrd.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/ip28.pdf#page=99.

Ortiz-Pradillo, Juan Carlos. (2023) 'Compensation for Wrongful Convictions in Spain'. In Compensation for Wrongful Convictions. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003229414-5.

Osamor, Robert. (2022) 'The Criminal Processes and Plea-Bargaining in Nigeria'. AFJCLJ, 39-45. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022343310382205.39.

Pfeiffer, Christian. (2014) 'Parallel Justice - Why Do We Need a Strengthening of the Victim in Society?' In International Perspectives of Crime Prevention 6: Contributions from the 7th Annual International Forum 2013 within the German Congress on Crime Prevention, 6:95-120. https://www.praeventionstag.de/dokumentation/download.cms?id=1471.

Poyser, Sam, and Rebecca Milne. (2021) 'The Time in between a Case of "Wrongful" and "Rightful" Conviction in the UK: Miscarriages of Justice and the Contribution of Psychology to Reforming the Police Investigative Process'. International Journal of Police Science and Management 23, no. 1. https://doi.org/10.1177/14613557211006134.

Susilo, Erwin, Mohd Din, Suhaimi, and Teuku Muttaqin Mansur. (2024) 'Justice Delayed, Justice Denied: A Critical Examination of Repeated Suspect Status in Indonesia'. Hasanuddin Law Review 3, no. 3: 342–57. https://doi.org/10.20956/halrev.v10i3.6088.

Wiebke, Steffen. (2014) 'More Prevention, Less Victims'. Vol. 6. http://www.praeventionstag.de/dokumentation/download.cms?id=1498.

Zargar, Zulkifl M. (2020) 'Secret Faits Accomplis: Declination Decisions, Nonprosecution Agreements, and the Crime Victim's Right to Confer'. Fordham Law Review 89, no. 1.

Books:

Brookes, Derek R. (2023) Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice: The Case for Parallelism. Chicago: Eleven International Publishing.

Zedner, L., (2004), Criminal Justice (4th ed.). Oxford University Press..

LaFave, W. R., Israel, J. H., King, N. J., & Kerr, O. S. (2015), Criminal Justice. Oxford University Press..

Criminal Procedure (5th ed.). West Academic Publishing.

Herman, S. (2010), Due Process and Victims’ Rights: The New Law and Politics of Criminal Justice. University of Toronto Press.

Herman, Susan. (2010) Parallel Justice for Victims of Crime. DC: National Center for Victims of Crime Washington.

Roach, K. (1999), Ideology in Criminal Procedure, or A Third “Model” of the Criminal Process. Yale University Press.

Marbun, Rocky and Mulyadi, Mahmud Rosalina, Fina. (2021) Criminal Procedure Law: Philosophical, Theoretical, and Conceptual Foundations. Publica Indonesia Utama.

Marzuki, Peter Mahmud. (2008) Legal Research. Jakarta: Kencana Prenada Media.

Sanders, A., & Young, R. (2010), Miscarriages of Justice: A Review of Justice in Error. Oxford University Press.

Mossman, E. (2012) Commissioned by Ministry of Justice Victims of Crime in the Adult Criminal Justice System: A Stocktake of the Literature. Ministry of Justice.

Packer, H. L. (1968). The Limits of the Criminal Sanction. Stanford University Press. Griffiths, J.

Ashworth, A. (2015), Parallel Justice for Victims of Crime. National Center for Victims of Crime.

Walker, C. (1999), Punishment, Communication, and Community. Oxford University Press.

Rogers, David, and Kerry Naughton. (2011) 'MOVING BEYOND SIDES: The Power and Potential of a New Public Safety Policy Paradigm 1 Moving Beyond Sides: The Power and Potential of a New Public Safety Policy Paradigm'. Portland, www.safetyandjustice.org.

Susilo, Erwin. (2020) Pretrial Issues, Compensation and/or Rehabilitation in Terms of Theory, Norms and Practice. Bandung: Alumni.

---. (2023) 'Pretrial Reconstruction, Compensation and / or Rehabilitation as a Means of Legal Protection for Suspects'. Master of Law Studies Program, Syiah Kuala University.

---. (2020) Indictment, Objection/Exception, and Legal Settlement. Bandung: PT Citra Aditya Bakti.

Duff, R. A. (2001), Sentencing and Criminal Justice (6th ed.). Cambridge University Press.

Internet:

ICJR, (2025). 'Torture and Arbitrary Arrest of Snail Finder by IR Police: ICJR Urges Systemic Reforms and Strict Punishment of Perpetrators'. https://icjr.or.id/penyiksaan-dan-penangkapan-sewenang-wenang-pencari-bekicot-oleh-polisi-ir-icjr-desak-reformasi-sistemik-dan-hukum-tegas-pelaku/.

González, Lidia, and Madrid' Pérez-Llorca. (2025) 'The Price of Freedom: Compensation for Unjustified Detention across the European Union'. International Bar Association. https://www.ibanet.org/article/c92b648d-5c33-418c-a087-ff4001c95815?utm_source=chatgpt.com.

Herman, Susan, Scott C. Newman, Paul F. Evans, Deborah A. Ramirez, Paul A. Logli, and Tracey Meares. (2001) 'Commentaries on: Trust and Confidence in Criminal Justice'. Office of Justice Programs (.gov). https://www.ojp.gov/sites/g/files/xyckuh241/files/media/document/189106-1a.pdf.

Herman, Susan, and Michelle Webster. (2005) 'Parallel Justice: A New Framework for Providing Justice for Crime Victims'. VOMA 19. https://www.skidmore.edu/campuslife/karp/book-reviews/Immarigeon-Review-of-RJ-on-the-College-Campus.pdf.

Project, Innocence. (2022) 'Key Provisions in Wrongful Conviction Compensation Laws'.https://www.law.umich.edu/special/exoneration/Documents/Key-Provisions-in-Wrongful-Conviction-Compensation-Laws.pdf.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.30659/ldj.7.3.375-391

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Law Development Journal has been indexed in: