Return of Sinamot Money from the Perspective of Al'adatu Muhakkamah (Analysis of the Decision of the Padangsidimpuan City Religious Court Number 129/Pdt.G/2015/PA.Psk)
Abstract
This paper is a study on the return of sinamot money in the decision of the Religious Court by examining based on the perspective of the fiqh rule Al'adatu Muhakkamah, which examines the reality that the lawsuit for the return of sinamot money submitted to the Padangsidimpuan City Religious Court, by the Panel of Judges was partially returned, with considerations that contain justice, certainty and legal benefits and cannot be separated from the consideration that custom is the law "al-adatu muhakkamah". Marriage dowry in Mandailing and Batak customs is generally known as Sinamot/Tuhor, referred to as Sinamot or Marhata Sinamot because it is a sale and purchase between the male party (paranak) and the female party (parboru) or it can also be said to be a dowry. Marhata Sinamot is one of the traditional events at the wedding and aims to explore the extent of the burden that can be shouldered by both parties, namely the male and female parties, so that the marriage can be carried out. In the Compilation of Islamic Law, Article 1 letter d states that dowry is a gift from the prospective groom to the prospective bride, whether in the form of goods, money or services that are not contrary to Islamic law, in line with this in chapter V of the Compilation of Islamic Law from Article 30 to Article 38 all discuss dowry with the provision that the dowry belongs to the wife after being given by the husband, but interestingly Article 35 paragraph 1 regulates that a husband who divorces his wife qobla al dukhul is obliged to pay half the dowry determined in the marriage contract. However, the reality in the decision of case 129/Pdt.G/2015/PA.Psk in the case of a divorce suit with a counterclaim for a full return of the dowry, but the Panel of Judges partially granted it with the consideration that after the marriage the Plaintiff and the Defendant had never had conjugal relations and the Plaintiff's status was still a girl, so the judge did istinbath law using the qiyas method of Article 35 paragraph (1) of the Compilation of Islamic Law for the case of a divorce suit. In addition, the judge's consideration also prioritizes customary law in the Mandailing indigenous community. In the customs of the mandailing community, if the marriage does not take place but the sinamot money has been given, and the cause is from the prospective husband, the sinamot money is considered forfeited, but if the cause is from the woman, she is obliged to return the sinamot money in full or larger. The decision of the Religious Court has provided justice, certainty, and legal benefits for the parties by deciding to grant in part, because part of the sinamot money has been used for the benefit of the party. with this decision, it is very wrong to say that customary law and positive law intersect, because in various conditions customary law and positive law work hand in hand to realize legal objectives in the frame of court decisions. Exploring the law that lives in the midst of the community where the parties are litigating is important, considering that society and custom are two things that cannot be separated. Society has lived with customary law even long before positive law existed, so the correlation between the two is a requirement for a quality decision from the perspective of sociological considerations. This research is expected to be an academic study among legal practitioners and academics, that customary law, positive law and Islamic law can work together to realize legal goals.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296448'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296448 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296449'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296449 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Books:
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296450'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296450 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Abdul Ghofur Anshori, (2011), Hukum Perkawinan Islam Perspektif Fikih dan Hukum Positif, Yogyakarta: UII Press.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296451'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296451 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Achmad Ali, (2009), Menguak Teori Hukum (Legal Theory) & Teori Peradilan (Judicialprudence): Termasuk Interpretasi Undang-Undang (Legisprudence) Volume I Pemahaman Awal, Jakarta: Kencana Prenada Media Group.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296452'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296452 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Achmad Ali, (2013), Menguak Teori Hukum (Legal Theory) dan Teori Peradilan (Judicial Prudence), cet. Ke-5, Jakara: Kencana Prenada Grup.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296453'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296453 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Ade Dedi Rohayana, (2008), Ilmu Qowa’id Fiqhiyyah: Kaidah-Kaidah Hukum Islam, Jakarta: Gaya Media Pratama.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296454'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296454 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Adesh Febriyeni dan Payerli Pasaribu, (2019), Perubahan Fungsi Sinamot pada Etnik Batak Toba, Jakarta: Kencana.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296455'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296455 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Ahmad Sarwat, (2019), Serial Fiqih Kehidupan 8: Pernikahan, Jakarta: Gaya Media Pratama.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296456'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296456 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Ali Raja Nasution, (2011), Penetapan Mahar Dalam Adat Mandailing Dan Dampaknya Terhadap Kelangsungan Pernikahan Ditinjau Menurut Hukum Islam (Studi Kasus Di Desa Tambusai Barat, Kecamatan Tambusai, Kabupaten Rokan Hulu)”, Skripsi S1 Fakultas Syariah dan Ilmu Hukum Universitas Islam Negeri Suska Riau, Pekanbaru.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296457'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296457 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Asy-Syarbini al-Khatib, (1998), Mughnii Muhtaaj Syarh al-Minhaaj, Jilid 3, Mesir: al-Baab al-Halabi.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296458'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296458 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Amir Syarifuddin, (2007), Fiqh Munaqahat Hukum Perkawinan Islam Di Indonesia: Antara Fiqh Munakahat dan Undang-Undang Perkawinan, Jakarta: Kencana.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296459'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296459 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Gultom Rajamarpodang, (1992), Dalihan Na Tolu Nilai Budaya Suku Batak, Medan: CV. Armada Medan.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296460'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296460 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Husnul Haq, (2017), Kaidah Al-„Adah Muhakkamah dalam Tradisi Pernikahan Masyarakat Jawa, Skripsi Institut Agama Islam Negeri Tulungagung, Jawa timur: IAIN Tulungagung.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296461'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296461 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Kementerian Agama Republik Indonesia, (2019), Al-Qur’an Dan Terjemahannya : Edisi Penyempurnaan. Jakarta: Kencana.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296462'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296462 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
M. Ali Hasan, (2006), Pedoman Hidup Berumah Tangga dalam Islam, Jakarta: Siraja Prenada Media Group.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296463'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296463 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Muhammad Fauzil Adhim, (2003), Kupinang Engkau dengan Hamdalah, Yogyakarta: Mitra Pustaka.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296464'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296464 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Pandapotan Nasution, (2005), Adat Budaya Mandailing Dalam Tantangan Zaman, Sumatera Utara: Forkala.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296465'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296465 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Ria Damayanti, (2019), Fenomena Jumlah Sinamot Dalam Perkawinan Suku Batak (Studi Kasus Di Desa Hajoran Julu, Kabupaten Labuhan Batu Selatan, Provinsi Sumatera Utara), Tesis S2 Fakultas Syari’ah dan Hukum Universitas Islan Negeri Sunan Kalijaga, Yogyakarta.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296466'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296466 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Saiful Jazil, (1998), Al-„Adah Muhakkamah, „Adah dan „Urf sebagai metode Istinbat Hukum Islam, Porsiding Halaqoh Nasional dan Seminar Pendidikan Fakultas Tarbiyah dan keguruan, Surabaya: UIN Sunan Ampel.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296467'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296467 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Tihami dan Sohari Sahrani, (2008), Fiqh Munakahat Kajian Fiqh Lengkap, Jakarta: Rajawali Pers, Cet. Ke-4, edisi ke-1.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296468'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296468 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Wahbah Az-Zuhaili, (2019), Fiqih Islam Wa Adillatuhu, Jilid 9, Terj. Abdul Hayyie al-Kattani.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296469'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296469 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Journals:
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296470'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296470 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Adesh Febriyeni dan Payerli Pasaribu, (2020), Perubahan Fungsi Sinamot pada Etnik Batak Toba, Jurnal Buddayah, Volume 2, No. 1.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296471'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296471 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Fatmah Taufik Hidayat, (2016), Kaedah Adat Muhakkamah dalam pandangan Islan (sebuah tinjauan sosiologi hukum), Jurnal Sosiologi USK, volume 9, No. 1, Banda Aceh: Universitas Syiah Kuala.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296472'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296472 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Lanna Khairani, (2019), Mangalehen Tuor: Fenomena Living Hadis dalam Adat Mandailing, Jurnal Mashdar, Volume 1, No. 1.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296473'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296473 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Muhammad Syukri Albani Nasution, (2015), Analisis Kompilasi Hukum Islam Tentang Tipologi Pelaksanaan Hukum Keluarga Islam di Mandailing Natal, Jurnal Manhaj, Volume 1, No. 9.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296474'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296474 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Rumasta Simalango, (2011), Fungsi Uang Jujur (Sinamot) Pada Perkawinan Menurut Adat Masyarakat Batak Toba Di Desa Sabungan Ni Huta, Kecamatan Ronggur Ni Huta, Kabupaten Samosir, Jurnal Pendidikan Ilmu-Ilmu Sosial, Volume 3, No. 2.
(mysql): SELECT * FROM citation_settings WHERE citation_id = '296475'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM metadata_descriptions WHERE assoc_type = 1048579 AND assoc_id = 296475 ORDER BY metadata_description_id DESC
Tommy Tius, (2018), Makna dan Fungsi Tradisi Sinamot dalam Pernikahan Batak Toba Di Kecamatan Mandau”, Jurnal Online Mahasiswa: Fakultas Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik, Volume 5, No. 2.
Yulia Risa dan Emizal Amri, (2021), Fungsi Tuor Bagi Orang Mandailing”, Culture & Society: Journal of Anthropological Research, Volume 3, No. 2.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.30659/ldj.6.1.1-17
(mysql): SELECT pa.*, a.*, COALESCE(stl.setting_value, stpl.setting_value) AS section_title, COALESCE(sal.setting_value, sapl.setting_value) AS section_abbrev FROM published_articles pa INNER JOIN articles a ON pa.article_id = a.article_id LEFT JOIN sections s ON s.section_id = a.section_id LEFT JOIN section_settings stpl ON (s.section_id = stpl.section_id AND stpl.setting_name = 'title' AND stpl.locale = 'en_US') LEFT JOIN section_settings stl ON (s.section_id = stl.section_id AND stl.setting_name = 'title' AND stl.locale = 'en_US') LEFT JOIN section_settings sapl ON (s.section_id = sapl.section_id AND sapl.setting_name = 'abbrev' AND sapl.locale = 'en_US') LEFT JOIN section_settings sal ON (s.section_id = sal.section_id AND sal.setting_name = 'abbrev' AND sal.locale = 'en_US') INNER JOIN article_settings ast ON a.article_id = ast.article_id WHERE ast.setting_name = 'pub-id::publisher-id' AND ast.setting_value = '36091' ORDER BY pa.issue_id, a.article_id
(mysql): SELECT pa.*, a.*, COALESCE(stl.setting_value, stpl.setting_value) AS section_title, COALESCE(sal.setting_value, sapl.setting_value) AS section_abbrev FROM published_articles pa, articles a LEFT JOIN sections s ON s.section_id = a.section_id LEFT JOIN section_settings stpl ON (s.section_id = stpl.section_id AND stpl.setting_name = 'title' AND stpl.locale = 'en_US') LEFT JOIN section_settings stl ON (s.section_id = stl.section_id AND stl.setting_name = 'title' AND stl.locale = 'en_US') LEFT JOIN section_settings sapl ON (s.section_id = sapl.section_id AND sapl.setting_name = 'abbrev' AND sapl.locale = 'en_US') LEFT JOIN section_settings sal ON (s.section_id = sal.section_id AND sal.setting_name = 'abbrev' AND sal.locale = 'en_US') WHERE pa.article_id = a.article_id AND a.article_id = 36091
(mysql): SELECT g.*, a.file_name, a.original_file_name, a.file_stage, a.file_type, a.file_size, a.date_uploaded, a.date_modified FROM article_galleys g LEFT JOIN article_files a ON (g.file_id = a.file_id) WHERE g.article_id = 36091 ORDER BY g.seq
(mysql): SELECT * FROM article_galley_settings WHERE galley_id = '9715'
(mysql): SELECT * FROM article_settings WHERE article_id = '36091'
(mysql): SELECT s.*, a.file_name, a.original_file_name, a.file_type, a.file_size, a.date_uploaded, a.date_modified FROM article_supplementary_files s LEFT JOIN article_files a ON (s.file_id = a.file_id) WHERE s.article_id = 36091 ORDER BY s.seq
(mysql): SELECT * FROM article_supp_file_settings WHERE supp_id = '7304'
(mysql): SELECT r.* FROM referrals r WHERE r.article_id = 36091 AND r.status = 2
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Law Development Journal has been indexed in: